Last November, I queued for pre-bought tickets to Breaking Dawn, the fourth instalment of the Twilight saga. I'd contemplated skipping work for the back to back Twiathelon followed by the premier screening, which still feels like a perfectly good idea. I've literally stepped into the Twilight Zone. Oh and I forgot to mention that I'm in my 30s.
Lets not get too cerebral here. I'm not going to quibble about the quality of Stephenie Meyer's writing, complexity of characters or originality of the plot. Meyer doesn't stray from convention. Its a proven formula. By her own admission, Meyer borrowed from the classics. She maintains that Twilight is loosely based on Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, New Moon, Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, Eclipse, Emily Bronte's Wurthering Heights and Breaking Dawn, Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream. Twilight is literally the stuff of great romances.
Edward's family is also a paradox. The Cullens are affluent, good looking, cultured with excellent taste in property. Despite these attributes, they remain compassionate and grounded, with strong family values. TIME book critic, Lev Grossman said ' ...their worlds have a free-standing integrity that makes you feel as if you should be able to buy real estate there....people do not want to just read Meyer's books, they want to climb inside and live there.'
" I don't have the strength to stay away from you anymore."
This brings us to the main protagonist. Bella is human, tangible and perfectly ordinary to the untrained eye. Tomboyish, she favours practicality over the whims of fashion and make-up. Meyer didn't stray from convention with our heroine either. Many of her traits are comparable to those of Austen's Elizabeth Bennett. She is spirited and defiant enough to challenge Edward. He subsequently cannot wield his powers over her. But unlike Bennett, Bella is co-dependent and no feminist. There is no room for gender politics in this fantasy novel, raising many questions ( along with the 50 shades camp) about modern women and the romance novel.
She sheepishly admitted to me that she's since gone back and watched it again with someone else.
My sister (who we'll call Clare, for privacy and street cred purposes) is also in her 30s and a fan of the films. She has been trying to indoctrinate me for months. She says, 'twilight gives you a sense that even though the guy is a monster, she's not afraid to love him.' I can see her point. Love is transcendent.
Meyer has sold 116 million copies worldwide, in 38 different languages, highlighting its cross cultural appeal. Crystal Mack of The Daily Herald wrote 'While teenage girls are the main audience, young boys and adults of both genders have also been swept up in the phenomenon.'
More recently there has been a resurgence of vampire TV. Being Human, Vampire Diaries, True Blood. To name but a few. They have fallen into the genres of sci-fi, comedy, horror, romance and fantasy. However Twilight is stored in my 'not to be taken too seriously' film genre. Boy meets girls. Boy and girl embarked on an intense, romantic journey. Nothing too thought-provoking. I can't wait for the final instalment.
You've sold it to me. I love a lot of old fashioned romance in gallons so I will check out Twilight.
ReplyDeleteoh great. Let me know what you think. Its not for everyone but it certainly kept me entertained.
ReplyDeleteI found my way here from Ronke's link. I loved your piece : )
ReplyDeleteI ignored Twilight on its initial release but somehow ( to this day I honestly don't know how) ended up with a 3 chapter excerpt of the book in my flat. It sat around ignored for ages and then one day I read it and that was it game over!
It appealed to the girl in me, who's alive and well and still loves the idea of being swept of her feet with a romantic passion by a 21st C hero. I loved it. The books are compulsively readable but simplistic in their delivery. But that's fine - I'm not the demographic! And like you I'm in my 30s and I know the vampire genre well.
The movies are a mixed bag. I think Eclipse is the best so far. Bring on Breaking Dawn pt 2, I for one, will be there at the Odeon watching it!
Thanks Yasmin. Further proof that having an intellect and being romantic are not mutually exclusive.I agree with you about the simplicy, it makes for great bedtime reading. The high brow stuff is valid but come November 16th, I'll also be at the Odeon ;-)
ReplyDeleteLol, you know the release date. Fantastic! I'll put that in my diary ; ) x
Delete